Comment choisir un poêlon : inox, fonte, antiadhésif… lequel convient à votre cuisine?

How to choose a frying pan: stainless steel, cast iron, non-stick… which one suits your kitchen?

Choosing a frying pan can seem complicated: materials, constructions and price ranges keep multiplying, and two models that look similar can behave very differently on the heat. Yet the right pan is first and foremost the right pan for the right use. Once you know your needs and the advantages of each material, the choice becomes much simpler. At Doyon Després, our conviction is clear: a good pan is not measured by its price, but by its performance and durability. Here are the guidelines that will help you make an informed choice, whether you cook at home or in a professional setting.

Frying pan or sauté pan: what’s the difference?

In Quebec, the term “poêle” commonly refers to a frying pan with low, flared sides, ideal for searing, browning and flipping food. The “poêlon” more often evokes a utensil with a long handle and higher sides, closer to a shallow saucepan, suited to sautés, sauces and cooking with liquid. In everyday use, the two terms are often used interchangeably. This article deals mainly with frying pans, but the advice also applies to sauté pans.

Why this choice matters

The material and construction of a pan directly influence the result on the plate. A pan that distributes heat poorly creates hot spots: the centre burns while the edges barely cook. Its lifespan also varies considerably, from a few years for an entry-level non-stick pan to several decades for quality stainless steel. Care and compatibility with your cooktop complete the picture.

In-store, three criteria are easy to check: a securely attached handle, a weight that inspires confidence without being cumbersome, and a thick, flat base.

The main types of pans

Type Advantages Limitations Ideal use
Non-stick

Little fat needed, easy cleaning

Not suitable for searing; limited lifespan Eggs, omelettes, crêpes, fish
Multi-ply stainless steel (3 to 5 plies) Versatile, heat distributed right to the sides, very durable Can stick if used incorrectly Meats, vegetables, sauces, deglazing
Stainless steel with encapsulated base

Good heat retention

Less even heat on the sides Everyday cooking
Carbon steel Even heat, oven-safe Requires seasoning and oiling; sensitive to acidic foods Experienced cooks, searing
Cast iron Intense sear, excellent heat retention Heavy, heats slowly; can rust on contact with water Experienced cooks, searing

Aluminium

Lightweight, very fast conduction

Cools quickly; bare aluminium is not induction-compatible Commercial kitchens


Stainless steel: versatility

Stainless steel is suitable for searing, sauces and deglazing—the process of dissolving the caramelized juices at the bottom of the pan with a liquid. In a multi-ply pan, the layers of metal cover the entire surface, including the sides, ensuring even heat. In a pan with an encapsulated base, only the bottom benefits from this construction: it heats and cools more slowly, and the heat concentrates under the pan rather than on the sides. This difference is major in use and often justifies the price gap between two models.

Non-stick: delicate foods

Non-stick excels with eggs, crêpes and fish. The most common coating is PTFE (polytetrafluoroethylene), a polymer known for its very low coefficient of friction. There are also ceramic coatings that are PTFE-free. In both cases, lifespan depends on use and product quality. Silicone or wooden utensils are preferred, as they preserve the coating. When used properly, these pans pose no health risk: simply avoid very high temperatures, heating an empty pan, and a heavily damaged coating.

Carbon steel and cast iron: intense heat

These two materials are aimed at those seeking a vigorous sear. Carbon steel is lighter than cast iron and is oven-safe, but it requires a bit of experience. Cast iron retains heat remarkably well, at the cost of significant weight. Both require seasoning—the formation of a protective layer of polymerized oil that reduces sticking and protects against rust.

Aluminium: commercial kitchens

Very light and responsive, aluminium is prized in commercial kitchens. However, it cools as quickly as it heats and is not compatible with induction when used on its own.

Compatibility with your cooktop

On induction, stainless steel, cast iron and carbon steel are fully compatible. The larger the contact surface with the element, the better the performance: a quality stainless-steel pan with a solid base is an excellent choice. A simple magnet lets you check compatibility: if it sticks to the base, the pan is suitable. You can also look for the induction symbol under the pan. On a gas range, stainless steel, cast iron and carbon steel are recommended, because the direct flame puts significant stress on the material. On an electric or ceramic glass surface, a perfectly flat base ensures more even cooking.

Which pan for your profile?

If you are just starting out, a quality non-stick pan for eggs, paired with a stainless-steel pan for everything else, covers most preparations. If you cook every day, multi-ply stainless steel becomes the foundation of your equipment, and carbon steel can be added if you like to sear and finish in the oven. In a professional context, aluminium is the common choice, but sturdy stainless steel and cast iron also offer the necessary durability.

If you want a product for life, choose a multi-ply stainless-steel pan without an encapsulated base or fragile coating. A quality pan, around $300, is a lasting investment that can even be passed down. It requires a little learning (preheating, fat), but it rewards you with exceptional performance and longevity. For a first pan, a size of 9 to 10 in (about 23 to 25 cm) suits most uses. The 12.5 in (about 32 cm) format is preferable for family meals.

Common mistakes to avoid

The most widespread error is heating a non-stick pan to high temperature: the coating degrades and food eventually sticks. Thermal shock, which occurs when a hot pan is plunged into cold water, is equally harmful. Let the pan cool before washing it by hand with mild soap and a soft cloth, as the dishwasher damages the finish.

Cast iron and carbon steel rust on contact with water: they must be dried thoroughly, then given a thin coat of oil. As for stainless steel, it is wrongly believed to be doomed to stick. Simply preheat the pan, add a thin layer of oil and let the food sear: if it still sticks, it is not ready to be turned.

Finally, avoid choosing according to price rather than use. Before buying, ask yourself what the pan will be used for: this question guides the choice better than any comparison chart.

In summary

The best pan is the one that matches the way you cook. Each material has its strengths, and a complete set often combines several. Our team will be happy to advise you.

Our suggestions

At Doyon Després, we offer pans for every budget. Escof represents our entry-level range, with an excellent quality-price ratio. Meyer sits in the mid-range and offers a very good balance between performance and durability. Scanpan, finally, belongs to the high end: it is the choice of those looking for a pan designed to last.